Decoding The Challenger Sales Methodology – Is It Effective or Just Hype?

The Challenger Sale book, first published in 2011, sparked debates in the sales industry at the height of its popularity as it positioned itself as ‘Anti Solution Selling’ – a widely adopted sales methodology at the time.

Authors Mathew Dixon and Brent Adamson argue that relationship-building is no longer the best sales method. Instead, after extensive research, I found that the best sales representatives love to debate and aren’t afraid to push the customer.

In this article, we go in-depth into the Challenger sale methodology, how to implement it and when not to. Read on to discover:

---

What Is the Challenger Sales Methodology?

The Challenger sales model is a process that aims to teach, tailor, and take control of the customer’s sales experience. The method involved sharing insights about an unknown problem or opportunity in the customer’s business that the sales rep’s business is uniquely equipped to solve.

It dispels a prospect’s assumptions or beliefs by pointing out their flaws and enables the sales rep to offer a better solution. Studies show that challenging customer assumptions, disrupting their thinking, and teaching them something new effectively maximize sales results.

The Challenger Sale Book Summary

While the Challenger Sale should be on every salesperson’s reading list, we understand time can often be scarce. Here are several key summaries from the book to help you improve your sales techniques. 

The Challenger Sale teaches that the best salespeople don’t just build relationships with customers – they challenge them.

Dixon, Adamson and their colleagues founded the “Challenger Sale methodology” based on their study of 6,000 salespeople during the Great Recession.

This was a time when traditional sales methods were struggling due to prolonged sales cycles – they found that there are five distinct types of salespeople;

• The Hard Worker
• The Challenger
• The Relationship Builder
• The Lone Wolf
• The Reactive Problem Solver

Overall, the Challenger Sales book argues that with the right training, application skills and tools for success, sales reps can take control of any customer conversation.

Challengers outperform other profiles by educating customers and challenging their preconceptions. 

By educating customers and challenging their preconceptions, Challengers can help them see opportunities they may have missed. 

This ability to question the status quo is more important than ever in our now information-rich world.

How Can Businesses Benefit from Challenger Selling?

According to Gartner*, most B2B buyers – a whopping 77%, in fact- have said their latest purchase was “very complex or difficult.” It’s not a surprise, considering modern products and services have become more complex than ever.

That is coupled with the fact that customers now hold more power than ever regarding research and comparison. It’s now taking more time for prospects to approach salespeople.

This means that when they reach your sales reps, they already know what they want, need, and can afford.

As a result, salespeople have to adapt their sales approach to match, and studies have found that the Challenger sale approach is the best solution to these types of complex sales conditions. 

5 Types of Sales Reps Profiles From the Challenger Sale

Let’s take a deeper look at the profiles of the sales reps from the challenger sales book. Bear in mind that it’s also important to recognize that salespeople with different profiles can still leverage their unique strengths within this framework:

1. The Hard Worker

The Challenger Sale defines the Hard Worker (21% of the sample) as:  

• Always willing to go one step further. 
• Super self-motivated.
• Determined to complete tasks. 
• Appreciates feedback for personal development. 
• Don’t give up easily!

Use your determination to thoroughly research customer pain points and industry trends. Your diligence can help you uncover unique insights to challenge customer thinking.

2. The Lone Wolf

The Challenger Sale defines the Lone Wolf (18% of the sample) as:

• They follow their instincts. 
• Have an abundance of self-assurance.
• They can be challenging to manage, although they can deliver adequate results. 

Channel your self-assurance into confidently presenting new perspectives to customers. Your instincts can be valuable in tailoring the approach to each client.

3. The Relationship Builder

The Challenger Sale defines the Relationship Builder (21% of the sample) as:

• Generous with their time.
• Maintains excellent connections with everyone.
• A classic consultative selling representative who asks lots of questions.
• They aim to build relationships with customers.

While building relationships isn’t the core of the Challenger approach, your ability to connect with people can help you deliver challenging insights in a way that doesn’t alienate the customer.

4. The Problem Solver

The Challenger Sale defines the Problem Solver (14% of the sample) as:

• Detail-oriented.
• Laser-focused on solving problems. 
• They are known for being reliable.
• Their primary focus is on customer service, not closing sales.

Your attention to detail can be invaluable in identifying complex issues that customers might not see. Use this skill to present unique solutions that challenge the status quo.

5. The Challenger

Finally, the Challenger Sales personality (27% of the sample) is defined as:

• Loves to debate and isn’t afraid to push the limits of the customer. 
• They know the customer’s business well, providing valuable insights the customer might not have thought of on their own.
• Possess the ability to have a changing view of the world. 

Challengers Sales Reps win deals by teaching prospects to change their perceptions, tailoring their sales approach to the lead’s personal values and economic needs, and finally taking control of the sales process. 

How to Identify the Traits of a Challenger Sales Rep?

The Challenger sales rep excels at adopting unique perspectives when it comes to creating solutions for existing problems. They lead the way in challenging the norm and have the skill to get potential customers enthusiastic about these new opportunities.

Simultaneously, the Challenger sales rep can promote his or her products as the ideal innovative solutions to these problems. Salespeople who fall into the Challenger sales rep archetype also tend to do their homework regarding getting to know their customers.

Challengers aim to learn as much as possible about what drives a lead’s decision-making process regarding economics and values—enabling them to tailor their sales presentation to address these factors.

Finally, the Challenger sales rep relentlessly takes charge of conversations and fearlessly pushes leads toward closed deals by taking control at every opportunity. 

The Differences Between the Challenger Sales Rep and the Relationship Builder

The Challenger Sales Rep is someone who challenges the customer’s assumptions and offers insights that can help them solve their problems.

They are unafraid to push back and create constructive tension in the sales conversation. They are confident, assertive, and knowledgeable about their product and the customer’s industry.

The Relationship Builder is someone who focuses on building rapport and trust with the customer. They are friendly, empathetic, and attentive to customers’ needs and emotions.

They avoid confrontation and try to accommodate the customer’s time and preferences. They are loyal, supportive, and respectful of the customer’s opinions.

Knowing the difference between these two types of salespeople can help you identify your strengths and weaknesses and adapt your style to suit different situations and customers.

The Challenger Sales Rep tends to outperform The Relationship Builder in complex sales environments, where customers value expertise and innovation more than personal connection.

However, this does not mean that The Relationship Builder is ineffective or irrelevant. In some cases, building a strong relationship with the customer can be the key to closing a deal or retaining a loyal client.

3 Challenger Sales Techniques Every Salesperson Should Know

Spot your sales reps using these techniques. They may be a challenger salesperson:

1. Identify a unique opportunity to help a lead’s business solve a problem. Since, at this stage, you are attempting to teach the prospect something new about their business, the insight must be something that not even the prospect has thought of themselves. After all, Challenger Sales Reps are experts in changing perceptions. 

2. Present a solution to take advantage of your insight in the first step. Ensure you showcase how your solution can directly improve the lead’s business.

3. Apply firm but gentle pressure to your contact person when it comes to closing the deal. Refuse to negotiate on price while always emphasizing the added benefit that your solution will provide to their company. 

How to Adopt the Challenger Sales Methodology in 5 Steps

Before any sales reps can begin to adopt the Challenger sale methodology into their approach, they must be able to take control of the sale and be artful influencers who help customers make purchasing decisions.

Much like a rollercoaster, the Challenger sale quickly taps into the prospect’s ultimate fears, then raises their hopes by positioning the product as the solution and ends on an adrenaline-fueled high with the prospect eager and ready to buy.

Here are 5 challenger sales model examples to adopt into your process below:

1. Warm up Prospects and Prepare Game-changing Insights

In the first step of adopting the Challenger sale into your approach, you must prove to the prospect that you grasp the challenges they’re facing.

To achieve this, you must research your ideal target customers for data on their pain points, challenges, and needs. Here’s how you can do it effectively:

• Analyze industry reports and trends: Look for emerging patterns or shifts that your prospect might have overlooked.
• Study your prospect’s competitors: Identify strategies or innovations that your prospect could learn from or adapt.
• Examine your prospect’s public financial reports: Look for areas of underperformance or untapped potential.
• Review customer feedback and reviews: These can reveal pain points or desires that your prospect might not have fully addressed.
• Leverage your company’s unique data and experience: Draw on case studies or aggregate data from your other clients to provide a fresh perspective.

Armed with this information, you should only aim to provoke your prospects to consider other perspectives and solutions to their challenges. The more foundation you cover now, the easier it will be to sell later on in the process.

2. Reframe the Conversation

In the previous step, your prospect should have already shared their biggest problem, like they can’t increase conversions or are struggling to integrate new technology. But now, it’s your job to reframe their pain as an opportunity for growth.

The thing is, your prospect is likely to have big opinions on the matter but severely lacks any plans to solve the issue.

That’s where you can start to ask solution-focused questions that seek to weed out any misconceptions they might have about your service and begin to steer them toward the mindset that your solution is suitable.

To help you put this reframing technique into practice, here are some dialogue examples that demonstrate effective reframing in action:

Scenario	Prospect’s Statement	Salesperson’s Reframing Response
Cost Issue	“Your solution seems great, but it’s just too expensive for us right now.”	“I understand your concern about the cost. But let’s look at it differently. What’s the cost to your business if you don’t solve this problem? How much revenue are you losing each month due to inefficient processes?”
Technology Integration	“We’re hesitant to adopt new technology because it might disrupt our current workflows.”	“I see your point about potential disruption. But have you considered what if this short-term disruption could lead to long-term efficiency gains? How would it impact your team’s productivity if they could save 2 hours each day?”
Complacency	“Our current system works well enough. We don’t see a need to change right now.”	“I’m glad your current system is working for you. However, in our experience, ‘good enough’ can be the enemy of great. What if you could not just maintain your current performance, but significantly outperform your competitors?”
Lack of Urgency	“We might consider this next year when we have more budget.”	“I understand the inclination to wait. But let’s consider the opportunity cost of delaying. If implementing our solution could increase your efficiency by 20%, how much revenue would you be leaving on the table by waiting a year?”
Feature Focus	“Your competitor offers this additional feature that we think we need.”	“That’s an interesting point about the feature. But let’s take a step back. How critical is that specific feature to achieving your main business objectives? In our experience, clients often find that [your solution’s key benefit] has a much more significant impact on their bottom line.”

Now, the Challenger sale methodology comes to life as you begin to challenge your prospects to shift their focus to your solution.

It’s critical to note that you’re not selling your product here but rather evoking curiosity in the prospect while also putting pressure on the fact they have a problem that requires an answer they can’t solve.

3. Evoke Emotion

Customers don’t buy benefits, features, or advantages – they buy emotions. That’s why, to sell your product or service effectively, you need to show the benefits versus telling them the features of your product.

Even in B2B sales, emotions play a vital role in the sale of your solution.

A great way to use emotions to shift prospects’ perspectives is to use storytelling as a sales tool. For instance, you could either tell your prospect how great your solution is, or you could share a true story of how it improved someone’s life or business.

4. Highlight Your Value Proposition

At this stage, your primary objective is to inform your prospect about what the ideal solution looks like for their issue without referencing the product itself.

Don’t worry; there is a method to the madness! By introducing the answer to the prospect first, you’ve already sold them on the idea when you finally present the product.

Guide your prospect on the possibilities for solving their problem by using techniques that reframe their perspective, such as:

• Take the time to clarify any uncertainties the prospect may have. Connect the necessary dots for them and point them out to speed up the process.
• Tell a story to open your prospect’s imagination about the future if they decide to take action – or not. What will get worse for them?

5. Introduce the Product

If you’ve followed the other steps exactly, this last one should be easy. Up until now, you’ve pinpointed or discovered the prospect’s problem, reframed it, gained their trust and offered up a solution to solve it. All you have to do now is unveil the solution to help them.

Want to simplify and shorten the buying process? Become a Product Expert.

What Are the Advantages and Disadvantages of the Challenger Sales Approach?

Like any sales method, the Challenger sale, too, has both positive and negative aspects. Luckily, there are several positives as well as downsides.

One notable positive aspect is that the approach aims to grasp and prioritize the customer’s value and economic drivers. This effort gives customers a unique perspective on the product, a challenge that many other sales methodologies often find difficult to address.

However, the approach is suitable only for long, complex sales cycles, which means you’ll likely require your highest-performing sales reps on the case.

Sales reps with less skill and a background in traditional relationship selling experience may feel like they’re working backward and, thus, be far less successful with attempting the challenger sales methodology.

Discover the pros and cons of challenger sales illustrated below:

How Challenger Sales Compare to 5 Popular Sales Methodologies

When choosing a sales approach, it’s helpful to see how different methods stack up. Here’s a quick comparison of Challenger Sales to other popular sales methodologies:

Sales Methodology	Key Focus	How It Compares to Challenger Sales
Solution Selling	Identifying customer problems and offering tailored solutions	Challenger Sales goes further by teaching customers about problems they might not know they have
SPIN Selling	Using specific types of questions to uncover customer needs	Challenger Sales is more proactive, with reps bringing new ideas rather than just asking questions
Consultative Selling	Understanding the customer’s business deeply	Challenger reps are more willing to respectfully disagree with customers and push their thinking in new directions
MEDDIC	Qualifying prospects based on specific criteria	Challenger Sales focuses more on how you engage with prospects, regardless of where they are in the buying process
Value Selling Framework	Aligning your product’s value with customer’s business drivers	Challenger Sales not only aligns with value but actively shapes the customer’s perception of value

Each of these methods has its own strengths, and the best choice often depends on your specific industry, products, and customers. The Challenger approach stands out for its focus on pushing customers’ thinking and bringing new insights to the table.

You don’t have to stick to just one method. Many successful sales teams blend different approaches to create a strategy that works best for their unique situation.

What Are the Impact of Emerging Trends on Challenger Sales?

As sales continue to evolve, several emerging trends may impact the relevance and application of the Challenger methodology:

1. AI-Driven Insights: With artificial intelligence becoming more prevalent in sales tools, reps may have access to deeper, more nuanced insights about customer businesses.
   
   This could enhance a Challenger rep’s ability to provide valuable perspectives, but it may also mean that customers have access to similar insights. Challenger reps might need to focus more on interpreting and applying these insights in unique ways.
   
2. Changing Buyer Behavior: As buyers become more informed and self-directed in their purchasing journey, the window for challenging their thinking may narrow. Challenger reps might need to engage earlier in the process or find new ways to add value to well-informed customers.
   
3. Remote Selling: Let’s acknowledge that virtual sales meetings are here to stay, so Challenger reps may need to adapt their techniques for digital environments. Building rapport and reading customer reactions can be more challenging in virtual settings, requiring new skills and approaches.
   
4. Increased Focus on Customer Experience: As businesses prioritize overall customer experience, Challenger reps may need to balance their provocative insights with a more holistic, long-term view of the customer relationship.
   
5. Data Privacy Concerns: Stricter data protection regulations might limit the amount of information available to sales reps. Challenger reps may need to rely more on their ability to ask insightful questions rather than coming armed with detailed customer data.

These trends suggest that while the core principles of the Challenger approach – teaching, tailoring, and taking control – are likely to remain relevant, the specific tactics and skills required may need to evolve. 

Successful sales organizations will need to stay agile, continuously adapting their approach to meet changing market conditions and customer expectations.

Does the Challenger Selling model work?

If you’re still wondering, “Does the challenger sales model work?” Here’s the hard data that the study produced, mentioned in the book.

• 40% of sales performers primarily used a Challenger style – In comparison to any one of the other four sales styles the book identified. (The Hard Worker, The Relationship Builder, The Lone Wolf and The Problem Solver.)
  
• Just a mere 7% of top performers took The Relationship Builder approach – which coincidentally was the worst-performing profile.
  
• Over 50% of expert performers fit the challenger persona in complex sales.

While the original study provided compelling evidence for the Challenger Sales Model, more recent case studies have continued to support its effectiveness.

Here are companies that have implemented the Challenger Sales Model, which presented some impressive results:

• SAP reported that Challenger-trained individuals closed 26% more deals, brought in 27% more sales revenue, and shortened sales cycles by more than a month on average.
  
• Xerox saw a 17% increase in sales and a 50% increase in the quality of coaching effectiveness after adopting Challenger skills and behaviors.

Here at SOCO, we offer Controller Selling training that incorporates some of the Challenger-inspired advanced skills reps need to be confident and competent enough to take big deals over the line.

We tailor our programs to each client’s unique needs and industry challenges and by combining the strengths of the Challenger model with our unique approach, we equip sales teams with a versatile, cutting-edge skill set that drives results in today’s complex B2B environments.

Our clients don’t just learn a methodology; they develop a tailored sales strategy that sets them apart in their industry.

SOCO’s Opinion on the Challenger Sale

Above all, incorporating sales techniques from The Challenger Sale takes experience and effort.

While it can be useful when done right, when attempted by inexperienced and not naturally tactful aggressive salespeople, it can backfire and lead to lost sales instead of increased sales.

So, It’s essential to understand the book’s concepts whilst building your expertise to ensure you’re using the appropriate technique that the deal requires. 

That being said, we at SOCO believe the core principles of the Challenger Sales Method remain highly relevant today. The method’s emphasis on providing unique insights and challenging customer assumptions is perhaps even more crucial now, given how easily buyers can access information online.

We recognize that the application of these principles needs to be nuanced and adaptable. Today’s market demands a more consultative approach, blending Challenger techniques with deep empathy and understanding of customer needs. 

We’ve found that the most successful sales professionals are those who can challenge customers’ thinking while also building strong, trust-based relationships.

Nowadays, buyers often come to the table well-informed, and the Challenger approach of offering novel insights becomes even more valuable.

It’s becoming more than just about presenting information. It’s more about contextualizing it for the customer’s specific situation and helping them navigate complex decision-making processes.

We advocate for a balanced approach that incorporates the best of the Challenger method while remaining flexible and attuned to individual customer needs.

This might mean using Challenger techniques to open new perspectives but then switching to a more collaborative, problem-solving mode as the conversation progresses.

Ultimately, the key is to use the Challenger method as part of a broader, adaptable sales strategy. 

When applied thoughtfully and in conjunction with other proven sales techniques, it can be a powerful tool for driving sales success.